Tuesday, October 19, 2010


Of Turning Japanese

A scary chart from Mary Daly, vice president of the Federal Reserve Bank of San Francisco. (via Krugman, via Mark Thoma)

Brad DeLong doesn't believe the QE2 will be enough. (sorry no link) Dean Baker argues that we are already - as they used to say in Vietnam - in the shit. (sorry no link) If we cross past zero, it won't mark anything new just that we are continuing our descent of disinflation. The point when we entered a Keynesian situation is where we crossed the rubicon.

What is needed is a larger QE and more fiscal stimulus.

Democrats, the election, the stimulus and Keynes by Sewell Chan
But that seems unlikely, as long as the recovery plods along slowly. "It would be a mistake to attribute the distancing from Obama’s stimulus entirely to political caution or opportunism," said Robert S. Weisbrot, a historian at Colby College. "As much as those factors may be important, it is dismaying how little evidence there is to show for it. Maybe we need even more, but surely $800 billion should have counted for something"

Krugman blogs

During the pre-crisis period, spending grew slightly faster than GDP --that’s Medicare plus the Bush wars -- while revenue grew more slowly, presumably reflecting tax cuts.
What happened after the crisis? Spending continued to grow at roughly the same rate -- a bulge in safety net programs, offset by budget-slashing at the state and local level. GDP stalled -- which is why the ratio of spending to GDP rose. And revenue plunged, leading to big deficits.
But I’m sure that the usual suspects will find ways to keep believing that it’s all about runaway spending.
What the usually good Sewell Chan fails to report is that the much of the stimulus was ineffective tax cuts and that much of the rest was canceled out or negated by the anti-stimulus of the 50 state governments and the stalling of GDP growth. Currently the economy is growing too slow to create enough jobs and aggregate demand which is why we'll see more action from the Fed.

No comments: